Home  ›  US History  ›  Modern America  ›  Korean War  ›  Truman Fires MacArthur

Korean War · Washington and Tokyo · April 11, 1951

Truman Fires MacArthur: The 1951 Clash Over Korea

Truman fires MacArthur: that was the news on April 11, 1951, when President Harry S. Truman removed General Douglas MacArthur, the famous commander of the United Nations forces in Korea. MacArthur wanted to widen the war by bombing China; Truman wanted to keep it limited and avoid World War III. When the general took his case to the public, Truman removed him. It was one of the most unpopular decisions any president has made, and one of the most important.

General Douglas MacArthur in uniform with his officer

General Douglas MacArthur, commander of the UN forces in Korea until April 1951

Quick facts

Truman and MacArthur at a glance

DateAnnounced at 1 a.m. on April 11, 1951
WhoPresident Harry S. Truman relieved General of the Army Douglas MacArthur of all his commands
WhyMacArthur publicly opposed the president’s policy of a limited war in Korea
Last strawA letter to Congressman Joseph Martin, read in the House on April 5, saying “There is no substitute for victory”
ReplacementLt. Gen. Matthew B. Ridgway took command in Tokyo
BackingThe Joint Chiefs of Staff and Defense Secretary George C. Marshall agreed MacArthur should go
Farewell“Old soldiers never die” speech to Congress, April 19, 1951
ResultCivilian control of the military was upheld; the war stayed limited to Korea
The big picture in 30 seconds

Why the firing matters

April 11

1951, MacArthur relieved

7 million

people at his New York parade (estimate)

14 years

since MacArthur had last been home

48 years

MacArthur’s career as an Army officer

Two strong men

A president and a general

Douglas MacArthur was the most famous general in America. He had commanded in the Pacific in World War II, accepted Japan’s surrender, and ruled occupied Japan for five years. His landing at Inchon in September 1950 made him a hero again. Harry S. Truman, the plain-spoken president from Missouri, was his commander in chief.

The two men met only once, on Wake Island in the Pacific on October 15, 1950. MacArthur told Truman the war would be over by Christmas and that China would not come in, or would be slaughtered if it did. Six weeks later about 300,000 Chinese soldiers attacked, and the UN armies reeled back.

Different wars

MacArthur now wanted to bomb Chinese bases in Manchuria, blockade China’s coast, and use Chinese Nationalist troops from Taiwan. Truman and his advisers feared this would bring in the Soviet Union, which had the atomic bomb, and leave Western Europe open to attack. They chose to fight a limited war to save South Korea, not to conquer China.

The Constitution
Commander in chief
Article II of the Constitution makes the president the commander in chief of the armed forces. Generals carry out the policy that elected leaders set.
Official portrait of General Omar Bradley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, in 1949
General Omar Bradley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, backed the president.
Where it happened

The war MacArthur wanted

China’s armies were supplied from bases in Manchuria, just across the Yalu River from North Korea. Truman allowed American planes to bomb the Korean ends of the Yalu bridges but not to cross into China. MacArthur called this an “enormous handicap, without precedent in military history.”

By March 1951 General Matthew Ridgway’s Eighth Army had pushed the Chinese back to about the 38th parallel. Truman saw a chance to start peace talks. MacArthur saw a chance to win and pushed for an all-out war.

The wider war MacArthur wanted, 1950–1951
SeoulPyongyangYalu bridgesChinese bases in ManchuriaCHINA (Manchuria)NORTH KOREASOUTH KOREAYellow SeaSea of JapanJAPAN38th parallel
Chinese armies crossing the Yalu, Oct.–Nov. 1950Front line, spring 1951 (approx.)38th parallel

Simplified map. MacArthur wanted to bomb the Chinese bases and bridges north of the Yalu River. Truman refused.
How it happened

From Wake Island to the firing

The quarrel grew over six months.

1. Oct. 15, 1950
Wake Island

Truman and MacArthur meet. MacArthur says China will not enter the war in force.

2. Nov. 1950
China attacks

Chinese armies drive the UN out of North Korea. MacArthur blames the limits on bombing China.

3. Dec. 1950
Gag order

Truman orders all officers to clear statements on foreign policy with Washington.

4. March 24, 1951
MacArthur’s ultimatum

He threatens China on his own, wrecking a peace offer Truman was about to make.

5. April 5, 1951
The Martin letter

Republican leader Joseph Martin reads MacArthur’s letter attacking the policy to Congress.

6. April 11, 1951
Relieved

Truman fires MacArthur and names Ridgway to replace him.

April 1951

“Old soldiers never die”

The news broke at a press conference called at 1 a.m. on April 11. MacArthur heard it on the radio in Tokyo before the official message reached him. Across America the reaction was fury. Telegrams poured into Congress, flags flew at half-staff, and some Republicans talked of impeaching the president.

MacArthur came home for the first time in 14 years. On April 19 he spoke to a joint session of Congress, ending with a line from an old Army song: “Old soldiers never die; they just fade away.” The next day millions of people cheered him in a ticker-tape parade in New York City.

The hearings

In May and June the Senate held long hearings. The Joint Chiefs of Staff testified that MacArthur’s plan was too dangerous. General Omar Bradley said that a war with China would be “the wrong war, at the wrong place, at the wrong time, and with the wrong enemy.” Slowly, public anger cooled, and MacArthur did fade away from public life.

General Douglas MacArthur speaking to a huge crowd at Soldier Field in Chicago in April 1951
MacArthur speaks to a crowd at Soldier Field, Chicago, after his return in April 1951.
A political storm
Truman pays the price
Truman’s approval rating sank as low as 22 percent by early 1952, one of the lowest of any president. He decided not to run again in 1952.
The people involved

The people in the clash

Portrait of Harry S. Truman
Harry S. Truman
1884–1972
33rd President

Fired the general to defend the president’s authority, knowing it would be deeply unpopular.

Read more →
Portrait of Douglas MacArthur
Douglas MacArthur
1880–1964
UN Commander, 1950–1951

Believed there was “no substitute for victory” and took his disagreement to Congress and the public.

Read more →
Portrait of Omar Bradley
Omar Bradley
1893–1981
Chairman, Joint Chiefs of Staff

The World War II general who told the Senate a war with China would be “the wrong war.”

Portrait of Matthew Ridgway
Matthew Ridgway
1895–1993
MacArthur’s replacement

The Eighth Army commander who turned the war around in early 1951 and took over as UN commander.

Why it mattered

Civilian control of the military

Truman later said he fired MacArthur because he would not respect the authority of the president, not because of the general’s ideas. The principle that elected leaders, not generals, decide when and how America goes to war came through the storm stronger than before.

The firing also shaped the Cold War. Korea stayed a limited war, fought inside Korea without atomic weapons, and later presidents followed the same rule in Vietnam and other conflicts. Most historians now say Truman made the right decision, even though it cost him dearly at the time.

1950
Wake Island meeting
1951
MacArthur relieved
1951
farewell to Congress
1952
Truman does not run again
Two views

MacArthur versus Truman

Both men wanted to stop Communism. They disagreed about how.

MacArthur“No substitute for victory”
Win the war in Korea by striking China itself. Fighting with one hand tied behind your back only wastes lives.
TrumanA limited war
Save South Korea, but keep the war small. A war with China could bring in the Soviet Union and start World War III.
The ruleWho decides?
Under the Constitution, the president makes war policy. A general may disagree in private but must not fight the policy in public.
The alliesWorried friends
Britain and other UN allies feared a wider war in Asia would leave Europe defenseless against the Soviet army.

“I fired him because he wouldn’t respect the authority of the President.”

Harry S. Truman
Quoted in Plain Speaking, by Merle Miller (1974)

The bigger story

The Korean War, 1950–1953

Our Korean War overview tells the whole story in one place: how Korea was divided, the three years of fighting, the leaders, and why the war still matters.

Go deeper

Books and sources

Keep exploring

More on the Korean War

Editor note (visitors never see this): click the menu box below and choose the Korean War Pages menu, then Update.