Home  ›  US History  ›  Expansion and Civil War  ›  Missouri Compromise

Expansion and Civil War · Washington, D.C. · 1819–1821

The Missouri Compromise of 1820

In 1819 Missouri asked to join the Union as a slave state, and a fight broke out in Congress that frightened the whole nation. After a year of bitter debate, Henry Clay and others found a deal: Missouri would come in with slavery, Maine would come in free, and slavery would be banned in the rest of the Louisiana Purchase north of the 36°30′ line. The Missouri Compromise kept the peace for 34 years, but it showed that slavery could tear the country apart.

Full-length portrait of Henry Clay standing beside a table with papers, painted by John Neagle

Henry Clay of Kentucky, Speaker of the House during the Missouri crisis, painted by John Neagle in 1843

Quick facts

The Missouri Compromise at a glance

DatesCrisis began February 13, 1819; first compromise signed March 6, 1820; Missouri admitted August 10, 1821
Passed byCongress, after votes of 134–42 (the 36°30′ line) and 90–87 (Missouri with slavery) in the House
Signed byPresident James Monroe
New statesMaine (free), March 15, 1820; Missouri (slave), August 10, 1821
The lineLatitude 36°30′ north, Missouri’s southern border, drawn west across the Louisiana Purchase
Balance12 free states and 12 slave states, so neither side controlled the Senate
Key figuresHenry Clay, James Tallmadge Jr., Jesse B. Thomas, Rufus King, James Monroe
Ended byThe Kansas-Nebraska Act (1854); the Supreme Court called it unconstitutional in the Dred Scott case (1857)
The big picture in 30 seconds

Why the Missouri Compromise matters

24

states after 1821: 12 free, 12 slave

36°30′

the dividing line

10,222

enslaved people in Missouri, 1820 census

34 years

until its repeal in 1854

The Tallmadge Amendment

Why Missouri caused a crisis

Missouri was the first state to be carved wholly out of the Louisiana Purchase west of the Mississippi. By 1819 about 66,000 people lived there, around one in six of them enslaved, mostly settlers from Kentucky, Tennessee and Virginia who had brought enslaved people with them. When Missouri asked to become a state, everyone assumed it would allow slavery.

Then on February 13, 1819, James Tallmadge Jr., a congressman from New York, proposed an amendment: no more enslaved people could be brought into Missouri, and children born to enslaved parents after statehood would be freed at age 25. The House, where the more populous North had a majority, passed it. The Senate, evenly split between free and slave states, voted it down. Congress went home deadlocked.

More than one state

Southerners saw the amendment as an attack on their right to take slaves into the West, and on slavery itself. Northerners argued that Congress had the power to keep slavery out of new states, as the Northwest Ordinance had done north of the Ohio River in 1787. Senator Rufus King of New York called slavery a violation of the law of nature. Behind the moral argument was a fight for power: if Missouri came in as a slave state, slave states would hold a majority in the Senate.

The Senate balance
Free states and slave states, 1819–1821
Early 181911 free – 10 slave
Dec. 181911 free – 11 slave
March 182012 free – 11 slave
August 182112 free – 12 slave
Blue = free states, red = slave states. Each state had two senators, so whoever had more states could block the other side in the Senate.
Thomas Jefferson, April 1820
“A fire bell in the night”
“This momentous question, like a fire bell in the night, awakened and filled me with terror. I considered it at once as the knell of the Union.” The retired president feared the line would one day split the nation.
Where it happened

Splitting the West in two

The compromise did three things. Missouri was admitted as a slave state. Maine, until then part of Massachusetts, was admitted as a free state, keeping the balance in the Senate at 12 to 12. And in the rest of the Louisiana Purchase, slavery was “forever prohibited” north of latitude 36°30′, which is Missouri’s southern border.

On paper the North got far more land, most of the Great Plains. But much of it was then thought to be a desert, and the South got Missouri and the Arkansas Territory right away. The line said nothing about land the United States did not yet own. When the Mexican-American War added huge new lands in 1848, the fight began all over again.

Free and slave after the Missouri Compromise, 1820–1821
WashingtonSt. LouisUNORGANIZED TERRITORY(closed to slavery)ARKANSAS TERR.SLAVE STATESFREE STATESSPANISH LANDS36°30′ lineAtlantic OceanFLORIDABRITISH NORTH AMERICAMissouriMaine
Free statesSlave statesTerritory closed to slaveryTerritory open to slaveryMissouri (slave state, 1821)Maine (free state, 1820)
The 36°30′ line

Simplified map. Florida became American in 1821 and a slave state in 1845. Borders in the far West followed the 1819 treaty with Spain.
How the compromise was made

A year of argument

It took two sessions of Congress and two separate compromises to settle Missouri.

1. Feb. 13, 1819
Tallmadge’s amendment

A New York congressman proposes gradually ending slavery in Missouri. The House passes it; the Senate rejects it.

2. Dec. 1819
Maine asks to join

Maine applies for statehood. The Senate ties it to Missouri, so one free state and one slave state come in together.

3. Feb. 17, 1820
The Thomas proviso

Senator Jesse B. Thomas of Illinois adds the 36°30′ line, closing the northern Louisiana Purchase to slavery.

4. March 2–6, 1820
The deal passes

Speaker Henry Clay steers the pieces through the House in separate votes. President Monroe signs on March 6.

5. July 1820
A new problem

Missouri’s constitution bars free Black people from entering the state, though they were citizens of some Northern states.

6. Feb. 1821
The second compromise

Clay arranges a deal: Missouri must promise not to deny the rights of any citizen. It is admitted on August 10, 1821.

Votes in the House, March 2, 1820

A deal nobody loved

The compromise passed only because Henry Clay, the Speaker of the House, split it into pieces. Northerners voted for the 36°30′ line, 134 to 42. The vote to let Missouri in without restricting slavery was far closer: 90 to 87. Just enough Northern members, later mocked as “doughfaces,” voted with the South. Clay then made sure the bill went to the Senate before opponents could ask to reconsider.

President James Monroe, a Virginia slaveholder, worried that Congress had no power to ban slavery in a territory. His cabinet, including Secretary of State John Quincy Adams and Secretary of War John C. Calhoun, told him it did, and he signed. Adams was not fooled about what had happened. In his diary he called the debate “a title-page to a great, tragic volume.”

Clay earns a nickname

Clay’s skill in 1820 and 1821, later repeated with the Compromise Tariff of 1833 and the Compromise of 1850, earned him the name “the Great Compromiser.”

Historic map of the United States showing the Missouri Compromise line of 1820
A historical map of the Missouri Compromise: free and slave areas in 1820.
John Quincy Adams, 1820
“A title-page”
“I take it for granted that the present question is a mere preamble — a title-page to a great, tragic volume.”
The lawmakers and the critics

Who settled the Missouri question

Portrait of Henry Clay
Henry Clay
1777–1852
Speaker of the House

The Kentucky leader who pushed both Missouri compromises through Congress and became known as the Great Compromiser.

Read more →
Portrait of James Monroe
James Monroe
1758–1831
President of the United States

Signed the compromise in his first term. The quiet years that followed are called the Era of Good Feelings.

Read more →
Portrait of Rufus King
Rufus King
1755–1827
Senator from New York

A signer of the Constitution who led the Senate fight to keep slavery out of Missouri.

Portrait of John Quincy Adams
John Quincy Adams
1767–1848
Secretary of State

Backed the compromise in Monroe’s cabinet but privately predicted that slavery would one day break the Union.

Read more →
Portrait of Thomas Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson
1743–1826
Former president

From Monticello he warned that a line dividing the nation by slavery would never be erased.

Read more →
Portrait of John C. Calhoun
John C. Calhoun
1782–1850
Secretary of War

Accepted the compromise in 1820 but later became the South’s fiercest defender of slavery in the West.

Why it mattered

From compromise to Civil War

For a generation the Missouri Compromise worked. Arkansas (1836) and Florida (1845) came in as slave states, Michigan (1837) and Iowa (1846) as free states, nearly always in pairs. But the arguments never went away. The Mexican-American War added land the line did not cover, and Congress needed the Compromise of 1850 to settle it.

In 1854 the Kansas-Nebraska Act threw out the 36°30′ line and let settlers in Kansas and Nebraska vote on slavery. Fighting broke out in “Bleeding Kansas,” and the new Republican Party was founded to stop the spread of slavery. In 1857 the Supreme Court ruled in the Dred Scott case that Congress had never had the power to ban slavery in a territory, so the Missouri Compromise had been unconstitutional all along. Abraham Lincoln’s election on a promise to keep slavery out of the territories led directly to secession and the Civil War.

1845
Florida and Texas join as slave states
1850
the Compromise of 1850
1854
Kansas-Nebraska Act repeals the line
1857
Dred Scott decision
The deal in one look

What each side got

The compromise was really three bargains rolled into one.

For the SouthMissouri, a slave state
Missouri entered the Union with slavery allowed and no limit on bringing enslaved people in. The Arkansas Territory, south of the line, stayed open to slavery too.
For the NorthMaine, a free state
Maine split from Massachusetts and joined as the 23rd state on March 15, 1820, keeping the Senate balanced at 12 free states to 12 slave states.
For the futureThe 36°30′ line
Slavery was “forever prohibited” in the rest of the Louisiana Purchase north of the line, the land that became Kansas, Nebraska, Iowa, Minnesota and the Dakotas.
Year by year

Slavery and the West, 1787–1857

1787
The Northwest Ordinance bans slavery north of the Ohio River.
1803
The Louisiana Purchase doubles the nation.
1812
Louisiana becomes the first state from the Purchase, with slavery.
Feb. 13, 1819
The Tallmadge Amendment sets off the crisis.
Dec. 14, 1819
Alabama joins: 11 free states, 11 slave states.
March 6, 1820
President Monroe signs the Missouri Compromise.
March 15, 1820
Maine becomes the 23rd state.
April 22, 1820
Jefferson’s “fire bell in the night” letter.
March 2, 1821
The second Missouri Compromise passes.
Aug. 10, 1821
Missouri becomes the 24th state.
1850
The Compromise of 1850 settles the Mexican Cession.
May 30, 1854
The Kansas-Nebraska Act repeals the 36°30′ line.
March 6, 1857
Dred Scott decision rules the old line unconstitutional.

“This momentous question, like a fire bell in the night, awakened and filled me with terror. I considered it at once as the knell of the Union.”

Thomas Jefferson
Letter to John Holmes, April 22, 1820

The bigger story

Expansion and Civil War, 1820–1879

Our U.S. History era page shows how this fits into the whole story of a growing nation that split over slavery, from the Missouri Compromise to the Civil War and Reconstruction.

Go deeper

Books and sources