Home  ›  US History  ›  Expansion and Civil War  ›  Compromise of 1850

Expansion and Civil War · Washington, D.C. · 1850

The Compromise of 1850 and the Fugitive Slave Act

The Compromise of 1850 was a package of five laws that Congress passed in September 1850 to settle what to do with the huge lands won in the Mexican-American War. California came in as a free state, Utah and New Mexico could decide on slavery for themselves, the slave trade ended in Washington, D.C., and a harsh new Fugitive Slave Act forced Northerners to help capture people who had escaped slavery. It held the Union together for ten more years, but it angered both sides.

Photograph of Senator Henry Clay of Kentucky taken by Mathew Brady around 1849

Henry Clay, 73 years old, offered the plan that became the Compromise of 1850. Photograph by Mathew Brady, about 1849

Quick facts

The Compromise of 1850 at a glance

DatesClay’s plan offered January 29, 1850; the five laws signed September 9–20, 1850
Signed byPresident Millard Fillmore, who took office when Zachary Taylor died on July 9, 1850
New stateCalifornia, admitted as the 31st state and a free state on September 9, 1850
New territoriesUtah and New Mexico, where settlers would vote on slavery (“popular sovereignty”)
TexasGave up its claim to eastern New Mexico; the U.S. paid $10 million toward its debts
Fugitive Slave ActFederal officers had to return people who escaped slavery; anyone who helped them could be fined $1,000
Key figuresHenry Clay, Daniel Webster, John C. Calhoun, Stephen A. Douglas, Millard Fillmore
Lasted untilThe Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 reopened the whole question
The big picture in 30 seconds

Why the Compromise of 1850 matters

31

states after California joined: 16 free, 15 slave

5

separate laws in the package

$10 million

paid to Texas for its land claims

10 years

until the Civil War began

The question of the new lands

Why the nation needed a compromise

The Mexican-American War ended in 1848 with the United States gaining more than 500,000 square miles, including California, Utah and New Mexico. The Missouri Compromise line of 1820 had only covered the Louisiana Purchase, so nobody knew whether slavery would be allowed in the new lands. As early as 1846, Congressman David Wilmot had tried to ban slavery from any land taken from Mexico. His “Wilmot Proviso” passed the House several times but always failed in the Senate.

Then gold was found in California in 1848. By 1849 nearly 100,000 people had rushed there, and California wrote a constitution banning slavery and asked to join the Union. Its admission would give free states a 16 to 15 majority in the Senate. Southern leaders talked openly of secession, and delegates from nine slave states agreed to meet in Nashville in June 1850.

Five more quarrels

California was not the only problem. Texas claimed land as far west as Santa Fe, and Texans were threatening to march there. Northerners wanted to end the buying and selling of enslaved people in the nation’s capital. Southerners complained that Northern states refused to return people who had escaped slavery. On January 29, 1850, Henry Clay offered a set of resolutions that tried to answer every one of these complaints at once.

The Senate balance, 1845–1850
Free states before 185015
Slave states before 185015
Free states after California16
Each state had two senators. California broke the 15–15 tie, and no new slave state was ever admitted again.
John C. Calhoun, March 4, 1850
“The cords that bind”
Too sick to speak, Calhoun had his speech read for him. He warned that the bonds holding the Union together were snapping one by one, and that only protecting slavery in the West could save it. He died four weeks later.
Where it happened

Dividing the Mexican Cession

The compromise drew no new line across the map. California, whose people had already voted against slavery, came in as a free state. The rest of the Mexican Cession was split into the Utah Territory and the New Mexico Territory, and Congress left it to the settlers there to decide on slavery when they applied for statehood. This idea, called popular sovereignty, was championed by Senator Stephen A. Douglas of Illinois.

Texas gave up its claim to the land east of the Rio Grande around Santa Fe. In return, the federal government paid $10 million toward the debts Texas had run up as an independent republic. The border Texas accepted in 1850 is still its western border today.

The West after the Compromise of 1850
San FranciscoSalt Lake CitySanta FeSt. LouisCALIFORNIAUTAH TERR.NEW MEXICO TERR.TEXASOREGON TERR.UNORGANIZEDMEXICOPacific OceanGulf of MexicoSLAVE STATESFREE STATESINDIAN TERR.
Free states (California joins free)Slave statesUtah and New Mexico: settlers decideLand Texas gave up for $10 millionTerritory closed to slavery (1820)
Old 36°30′ line

Simplified map. Borders in the Southwest were settled again by the Gadsden Purchase of 1853.
How the compromise was made

Eight months of debate

The most famous debate in Senate history was followed by months of deadlock, until a younger senator found a new way to pass the plan.

1. Jan. 29, 1850
Clay’s plan

Henry Clay offers eight resolutions and spends two days defending them on the Senate floor.

2. March 4, 1850
Calhoun’s warning

John C. Calhoun’s last speech demands that the North stop attacking slavery or let the South go in peace.

3. March 7, 1850
Webster speaks

Daniel Webster backs the compromise “for the preservation of the Union,” including a tougher fugitive slave law.

4. July 9, 1850
Taylor dies

President Zachary Taylor, who opposed the deal, dies suddenly. Millard Fillmore becomes president and supports it.

5. July 31, 1850
The Omnibus fails

Clay’s single “omnibus” bill is picked apart in the Senate. Exhausted, Clay leaves Washington.

6. Sept. 9–20, 1850
Douglas passes it

Stephen Douglas splits the plan into five bills and finds a different majority for each. Fillmore signs them all.

The Fugitive Slave Act, September 18, 1850

The law that changed Northern minds

Of the five laws, the Fugitive Slave Act caused the most anger. Anyone claiming that a Black person had escaped from slavery could bring them before a federal commissioner. The accused person could not testify or ask for a jury. The commissioner was paid $10 if he sent the person south and only $5 if he set them free. Ordinary citizens could be ordered to join the hunt, and anyone who hid or helped a freedom seeker faced a $1,000 fine and six months in jail.

Free Black Northerners were now in danger of being kidnapped and sold. Thousands fled to Canada. In Boston, crowds rescued a man named Shadrach Minkins from a courtroom in 1851. In 1854 it took soldiers and a cannon to march Anthony Burns back to slavery, as 50,000 people lined the streets. Many Northerners who had never cared much about slavery now saw it reach into their own towns.

Uncle Tom’s Cabin

Angered by the law, Harriet Beecher Stowe wrote Uncle Tom’s Cabin. Published in 1852, it sold 300,000 copies in its first year in the United States and turned millions of readers against slavery.

1851 poster warning the Black people of Boston to watch out for kidnappers and slave catchers
“Caution!! Colored people of Boston”: a poster of April 1851 warning that police officers were acting as slave catchers under the new law.
The Underground Railroad
Escape to Canada
After 1850 the free states were no longer safe, so the Underground Railroad ran all the way to Canada. Harriet Tubman led dozens of people north in the 1850s.
The great debate

The senators who made the deal

Portrait of Henry Clay
Henry Clay
1777–1852
Senator from Kentucky

“The Great Compromiser” came out of retirement to offer the plan, his last great service to the Union.

Read more →
Portrait of Daniel Webster
Daniel Webster
1782–1852
Senator from Massachusetts

His Seventh of March speech for the compromise saved the deal but cost him the trust of antislavery voters at home.

Portrait of John C. Calhoun
John C. Calhoun
1782–1850
Senator from South Carolina

The South’s leading defender of slavery opposed the compromise and died before it passed.

Portrait of Stephen A. Douglas
Stephen A. Douglas
1813–1861
Senator from Illinois

The “Little Giant” split Clay’s plan into five bills and steered every one through Congress.

Portrait of Millard Fillmore
Millard Fillmore
1800–1874
President of the United States

Became president in July 1850 and signed all five laws, including the Fugitive Slave Act.

Read more →
Portrait of Zachary Taylor
Zachary Taylor
1784–1850
President of the United States

The war hero president wanted California and New Mexico admitted at once and threatened to veto a compromise.

Read more →
Why it mattered

Ten years of borrowed time

Most Americans greeted the compromise with relief, and President Fillmore called it a final settlement. It was not. The Fugitive Slave Act made slavery a daily issue in the North, and popular sovereignty gave Stephen Douglas the idea for the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854, which threw out the Missouri Compromise line and led to bloody fighting in Kansas.

Still, the ten years the compromise bought mattered. Between 1850 and 1860 the North built thousands of miles of railroads and factories, and its population grew much faster than the South’s. When the Civil War came in 1861, the Union was far better prepared to win it than it would have been in 1850.

1850
California joins as a free state
1852
Uncle Tom’s Cabin published
1854
Kansas-Nebraska Act
1861
the Civil War begins
The deal in one look

The five laws of 1850

Each law passed on its own, with a different group of Northern and Southern votes.

Sept. 9, 1850California Statehood
California joins the Union as a free state, tipping the Senate to the North.
Sept. 9, 1850New Mexico and Texas
New Mexico becomes a territory open to popular sovereignty, and Texas settles its border for $10 million.
Sept. 9, 1850Utah Territory
Utah, home of the Mormon settlers around Salt Lake City, becomes a territory where voters will decide on slavery.
Sept. 18, 1850Fugitive Slave Act
A tough new law makes the federal government and Northern citizens help capture people who escaped slavery.
Sept. 20, 1850Slave trade ends in D.C.
Buying and selling enslaved people is banned in Washington, D.C., though slavery itself stays legal there until 1862.
For the NorthWhat each side won
The North got California and the end of the D.C. slave trade. The South got the Fugitive Slave Act and no ban on slavery in the territories.
Year by year

From the Mexican Cession to Kansas, 1846–1854

Aug. 1846
The Wilmot Proviso tries to ban slavery in land taken from Mexico.
Jan. 24, 1848
Gold is found at Sutter’s Mill in California.
Feb. 2, 1848
Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo ends the Mexican-American War.
Nov. 1849
California approves a constitution that bans slavery.
Jan. 29, 1850
Henry Clay offers his compromise resolutions.
March 7, 1850
Daniel Webster’s Seventh of March speech.
June 1850
Southern delegates meet at the Nashville Convention.
July 9, 1850
President Zachary Taylor dies; Millard Fillmore takes office.
Sept. 9–20, 1850
The five compromise laws are signed.
April 1851
Thomas Sims is sent back to slavery from Boston.
March 1852
Uncle Tom’s Cabin is published as a book.
May 30, 1854
The Kansas-Nebraska Act reopens the slavery question.

“I wish to speak today, not as a Massachusetts man, nor as a Northern man, but as an American. I speak today for the preservation of the Union.”

Daniel Webster
Speech in the U.S. Senate, March 7, 1850

The bigger story

Expansion and Civil War, 1820–1879

Our U.S. History era page shows how this fits into the whole story of a growing nation that split over slavery, from the Missouri Compromise to the Civil War and Reconstruction.

Go deeper

Books and sources