Home  ›  US History  ›  Revolution and Founding  ›  Constitutional Convention

Revolution and Founding · Philadelphia · May 25 – September 17, 1787

The Constitutional Convention of 1787

In the summer of 1787, 55 delegates shut themselves inside the Pennsylvania State House in Philadelphia, with the windows closed to keep their debates secret. They had been sent to fix the weak Articles of Confederation. Instead they wrote a brand new plan of government, the Constitution of the United States, which is still in force today.

Howard Chandler Christy painting of the delegates signing the Constitution, with Washington standing at the front

Scene at the Signing of the Constitution of the United States, by Howard Chandler Christy, 1940

Quick facts

The Constitutional Convention at a glance

WhenMay 25 to September 17, 1787
WhereThe Assembly Room of the Pennsylvania State House (Independence Hall), Philadelphia
Delegates55 attended from 12 states; Rhode Island refused to send anyone
PresidentGeorge Washington, chosen unanimously on the first day
Chief plannerJames Madison of Virginia, who also kept the fullest notes
SecrecyNothing said inside could be printed or repeated; the windows stayed shut all summer
ResultThe Constitution, signed by 39 delegates on September 17, 1787
In forceJune 21, 1788, when New Hampshire became the ninth state to ratify
The big picture in 30 seconds

Why the Convention matters

55

delegates attended

4 months

from opening day to signing

39

delegates signed

About 4,500

words in the original Constitution

A failing union

Why a new constitution?

The Articles of Confederation, in force since 1781, created a “firm league of friendship” among 13 nearly independent states. There was no president and no national court. Congress could not tax. It could only ask the states for money, and they often sent little or none. It could not control trade, so states taxed one another’s goods. Changing the Articles required all 13 states to agree. The nation could not even pay its war debts or the soldiers who had won independence.

In 1786 delegates from five states met at Annapolis, Maryland, to discuss trade. Too few came to do anything, but Alexander Hamilton and James Madison persuaded them to call for a larger meeting in Philadelphia the next May.

Shays’ Rebellion

That winter, struggling farmers in western Massachusetts, many of them veterans, rose up against high taxes and courts that were seizing their farms. Led by Daniel Shays, a former Continental Army captain, about 1,500 of them marched on the federal arsenal at Springfield in January 1787. Massachusetts had to raise a private army to stop them; Congress could do nothing. Washington wrote that he was “mortified beyond expression.” Shays’ Rebellion convinced many Americans that the country needed a stronger government.

The opening words We the People on the original Constitution
“We the People,” the opening of the Constitution, written out on parchment by Jacob Shallus.
Behind closed doors
Madison’s secret notes
Madison sat at the front of the room every day and wrote down nearly every speech. His notes were published only in 1840, after every delegate had died. They are the main reason we know what was said.
Where it happened

Back to Independence Hall

The delegates met in the same room where the Declaration of Independence had been signed eleven years earlier. Washington rode up from his home at Mount Vernon and stayed at the home of Robert Morris. Delegates lodged at taverns and boarding houses nearby, and Franklin, the host, lived a block away. Congress itself was meeting in New York at the same time, which would become the first capital under the new Constitution.

The road to Philadelphia, 1786–1789
Springfield: Shays’ Rebellion 1787Annapolis Convention 1786New York: first capital 1789Philadelphia 1787Atlantic OceanBRITISH CANADAL. OntarioL. ErieN.H.MASS.NEW YORKPENNSYLVANIAVIRGINIAN. CAROLINAS. CAROLINAGEORGIA
Simplified map. Red dot: the Convention. Black dots: the events that led to it, and where the new government began.
Four hot months

From the Virginia Plan to the signing

The delegates met six days a week through a sweltering summer.

1. May 29
The Virginia Plan

Edmund Randolph presents Madison’s bold plan: a national government with three branches and a two-house Congress based on population. It becomes the starting point.

2. June 15
The New Jersey Plan

William Paterson answers for the small states: keep one vote per state and simply strengthen the Articles. The convention nearly breaks up over the question.

3. July 16
The Great Compromise

By a single vote, the delegates accept a House by population and a Senate with equal votes for every state. The deadlock is broken.

4. September 17
Signing day

Gouverneur Morris polishes the final text. Franklin urges unity. Thirty-nine delegates sign; three, Randolph, George Mason and Elbridge Gerry, refuse.

September 17, 1787

A rising sun

Benjamin Franklin, 81 years old and in pain, was the oldest delegate. On the last day his fellow Pennsylvanian James Wilson read his speech for him. “I confess that there are several parts of this Constitution which I do not at present approve,” Franklin admitted, but he doubted any convention could make a better one. He asked every delegate who still had objections to “doubt a little of his own infallibility” and sign.

As the last delegates were signing, Franklin looked toward Washington’s chair, which had a half sun carved on its back. Painters, he said, found it hard to show a rising sun from a setting one. “I have often in the course of the session … looked at that behind the President without being able to tell whether it was rising or setting. But now at length I have the happiness to know that it is a rising and not a setting sun.”

“A republic, if you can keep it”

According to the notes of Maryland delegate James McHenry, a lady asked Franklin as he left the hall, “Well, Doctor, what have we got, a republic or a monarchy?” He answered, “A republic, if you can keep it.”

Washington’s chair with a carved half sun on its back, in Independence Hall
The “rising sun” chair Washington sat in as president of the Convention. It is still in the Assembly Room.
Who was missing
Absent founders
Thomas Jefferson was in Paris and John Adams in London as diplomats. Patrick Henry was chosen as a delegate but refused to go, saying he “smelt a rat.” He later fought hard against ratification.
Framers of the Constitution

The framers

Portrait of James Madison
James Madison
1751–1836
Father of the Constitution

Short, shy and tireless, he studied history’s republics before arriving, drafted the Virginia Plan and later co-wrote The Federalist. Fourth president.

Read more →
Portrait of George Washington
George Washington
1732–1799
President of the Convention

Said little in debate, but his presence gave the meeting its authority, and everyone expected him to be the first president.

Read more →
Portrait of Benjamin Franklin
Benjamin Franklin
1706–1790
Elder statesman

The world’s most famous American, 81 years old. His good humor and appeals for compromise helped hold the convention together.

Read more →
Portrait of Alexander Hamilton
Alexander Hamilton
1755–1804
New York delegate

Wanted an even stronger government, with a president and senators serving for life. Then fought hardest of all for ratification.

Read more →
Portrait of Roger Sherman
Roger Sherman
1721–1793
Connecticut delegate

A self-taught former shoemaker and the author of the Great Compromise. The only person to sign the Association, the Declaration, the Articles and the Constitution.

Portrait of Gouverneur Morris
Gouverneur Morris
1752–1816
Pennsylvania delegate

Spoke more often than anyone and, on the Committee of Style, wrote the final wording, including the Preamble’s “We the People of the United States.”

Why it mattered

The fight for ratification

The Constitution would take effect when nine states approved it in special conventions. The country split into two camps. Federalists supported the new government. Anti-Federalists, among them Patrick Henry, George Mason and Samuel Adams, feared it would crush the states and the people’s liberties, especially since it had no bill of rights. To win over New York, Hamilton, Madison and John Jay wrote 85 newspaper essays, collected as The Federalist, still the best guide to what the framers meant.

Small states ratified quickly, and the Federalists won close fights in Massachusetts, Virginia and New York by promising amendments. On June 21, 1788, New Hampshire became the ninth state. The new government began on March 4, 1789, Washington took the oath as the first president on April 30, and in 1791 the first ten amendments, the Bill of Rights, were added.

June 21, 1788
ninth state ratifies
April 30, 1789
Washington inaugurated
Dec. 15, 1791
Bill of Rights ratified
27
amendments since 1787
Give and take

The great compromises

The Constitution was built from bargains. Four of them shaped the country for generations.

July 16

The Great Compromise

Big states wanted seats by population, small states one vote each. Roger Sherman and Oliver Ellsworth of Connecticut proposed both: a House based on population and a Senate with two members per state. It passed by one vote.

Slavery

The three-fifths clause

Southern states wanted enslaved people counted for seats in the House, though they could not vote. The delegates agreed to count three of every five, giving slave states extra power for decades.

August

The slave trade

Congress was barred from banning the import of enslaved Africans until 1808. It did so in the first year it could. A fugitive slave clause was also added.

September

The Electoral College

Should Congress or the people choose the president? Neither. Each state would choose electors, equal to its members of Congress, who would vote for president.

State by state

The race to nine

Each state held a special convention, elected by the voters, to accept or reject the Constitution. Some votes were unanimous. Others were very close: Massachusetts approved by 19 votes after John Hancock backed it with a list of proposed amendments, Virginia by 10 after a three-week debate in which Madison faced Patrick Henry, and New York by just 3.

North Carolina waited until Congress proposed a bill of rights. Rhode Island, which had boycotted the Convention, joined only in May 1790, after the new government threatened to tax its trade as if it were a foreign country.

The Federalist
85 essays by “Publius”
Hamilton wrote 51, Madison 29 and Jay 5, all under the pen name Publius. Federalist No. 10 and No. 51, both by Madison, explain why a large republic with checks and balances protects liberty.
1Delaware
Dec. 7, 1787 · vote 30–0
2Pennsylvania
Dec. 12, 1787 · vote 46–23
3New Jersey
Dec. 18, 1787 · vote 38–0
4Georgia
Jan. 2, 1788 · vote 26–0
5Connecticut
Jan. 9, 1788 · vote 128–40
6Massachusetts
Feb. 6, 1788 · vote 187–168
7Maryland
April 28, 1788 · vote 63–11
8South Carolina
May 23, 1788 · vote 149–73
9New Hampshire
June 21, 1788 · vote 57–47 · the Constitution takes effect
10Virginia
June 25, 1788 · vote 89–79
11New York
July 26, 1788 · vote 30–27
12North Carolina
Nov. 21, 1789 · vote 194–77
13Rhode Island
May 29, 1790 · vote 34–32

“A republic, if you can keep it.”

Benjamin Franklin
Asked what kind of government the Convention had created, September 1787 (from the notes of James McHenry)

The bigger story

Revolution and Founding, 1770–1819

Our U.S. History era page puts this in context: the road to independence, the Revolutionary War, the Constitution and the first presidents.

Go deeper

Books and sources

Keep exploring

More from the Founding era